Customize your website

PAM'S PEN



Pam Morrissey
Published on November 9th, 2009
Published on July 14th, 2010
Pam Morrissey RSS Feed

Uninspired trades program

Topics :
College of the North Atlantic , Labrador West

It costs a lot to introduce women to trades and technology.
Suzanne Charlton, community development coordinator with Women in Resource Development, was in Labrador West Nov. 3 to highlight the Orientation to Trades and Technology for Women program to women interested in the trades.
The six-month program is slated to begin at the local College of the North Atlantic campus Jan. 18 - it will run until July - and will provide hands-on training in several different trades including: carpentry, welding, heavy equipment operation, electrical, electrical engineering, blueprint reading, civil engineering, millwright, and motor vehicle repair.
The course, according to Charlton, also touches on academics, personal development, exploration of the natural resource sector, essential work skills and offers two weeks of job shadowing.
While the program certainly sounds like a great fit for someone interested in the trades, and would probably help women decide what trade they want to pursue since it touches on a little bit of everything, there's a pretty hefty price tag attached to the course.
It costs $10,000 to take the program and at the end of 24 weeks women aren't certified to do anything.
The group will receive certificates in workplace hazardous management information systems and first aid, but for $10,000 there should be a lot more.
While some women have gotten employment at the end of the program, Charlton said, most go on to pursue a trade. When you compare how much it costs to enroll in a trades program at the College of the North Atlantic, it would be cheaper to do two full-time trades than to go through the orientation program once.
It's also important to note most women who sign up for the course get funding from provincial and/or federal sources, so the taxpayers are picking up the tab for a program that may or may not result in employment.
Charlton explained it takes at least 10 women to put off the Orientation to Trades and Technology for Women, and it maxes out at 15.
While she noted it's a cost recovery program - the group has to pay for instructors and provides all the equipment and gear needed to complete the program (ie: hard hats and steel toe boots) - if every single woman who takes the course secures funding, one six-month course costs taxpayers at least $150,000.
Is it worth it? While the program certainly has merit - it's wonderful to be able to provide a safe and supportive environment for women to explore the trades - should the taxpayers be paying for someone to try trades on for size?
According to Charlton, the program also talks a lot about the challenges women face in the trades and technology industry and there is a lot of discussion around problem solving, women in society and gender sensitivity training.
It's important to discuss those issues - women do face significant barriers no matter what they choose to do - but in the presentation last week, Charlton didn't inspire confidence.
She gave examples of women being thwarted in male-dominated fields - one pilot apparently told a woman qualified to fly that if women were meant to fly, the sky would be pink not blue - and she pointed out women will have to overcome those kinds of attitudes if they choose a career in the trades.
While she stressed women can do any job a man can do, she was also quick to say women are "too nice" and need to be more assertive.
To any woman considering a job in the trades, Charlton's message was more intimidating than uplifting and just saying the Orientation to Trades and Technology for Women is an excellent program isn't enough to sell it.
Ultimately whether women in Labrador West will give the course the green light is up to them - registration is going on now until January - but from the outside looking in, it isn't all it's cracked up to be.


Comments

  • Username
    Frank
    - July 14th, 2010 at 11:48:29

    I was very impressed to see so many women now working in various trades.
    There are women operating heavy equiptment in Quebec and Ontario. They are more involved in adminstratives roles that men had problems with. A lot had to do with attitude and family clicks in the hospitals where every family member has an adminstrative role. Today, The province of Quebec cleaned up that mess.

    It's unfortunate to see all the fraud and overspending by men in governments. We very seldom hear of women taking advantage of the taxpayers purse.

    Women have become more assertive in the workforce. They are more of the teamwork type and not the big boss who sits on his butt all the time, puffing on his pipe...

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    suzanne
    - July 14th, 2010 at 11:48:12

    It seems Ms. Morrissey, that you have missed the point of the Orientation to trades and Tech program for women entirely. Far from being uninspiring, there have been 100 women here in Labrador and another 400 or so women who have participated in this very valuable program. I encourage you to ask any one of these women and they will solidly and wholeheartily endorse this program as transformational to their lives. I even have women asking if they can take the program twice!
    You see this program is about empowering women to break out of strereotypical careers that keep women at the lower end of the economic scale and dependent. Its an equity program which offers women an opportunity to try a trade career which they would not have had previously had access to and an opportunity to make a more positive career choice. Parents, school counsellors and career officers do not necessarily give their daughters, clients, or female students the information to make a choice for trades. In case you haven't noticed, women still only earn $.67 to men's dollar, so women's equity in the work force can be addressed by offering women a chance to earn a decent wage in trades or tech careers. Apparently the Province agrees because the high schools are now offering trades to high school girls and many of the apprenticeship organizations are supporting women with subsidies to encourage tradeswomen. Get with the program Pam, do your research as a reporter,we are not offering any luxury item here but a reality check for women who want to improve their lives. Negatively criticizing me and focussing on the cost is not constructive reporting but only serves to make you look an uninformed journalist. SC.

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    Resident
    - July 14th, 2010 at 11:48:06

    Well, Ms. Charlton you have some goodpoints. but for $10,000 there should be some certification so these women can use it to get jobs otherwise, it's you making money and they are Still in the low paying jobs.

    Submit a Comment

Submit a Comment

Submit a Comment

This form is NOT used for emailing the article to a friend. Please use the "Send to a friend" link at the top of the page for that purpose.

The Aurora is not responsible for posted comments. Please be polite and confine your comments to the subject of the posted story. If you have an account, please sign on to it..

(we keep all emails private)
Agreement

We ask that users remain courteous. You may not post insulting, discriminatory or inappropriate content, which may be removed at our discretion. We are not responsible for user content and opinions. Use of this site as well as content submission & ownership are governed by our Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.

Member organizations should be non-profit in nature, and promote legal activities. Any organization found promoting illegal activities or commercial products or services will be deleted from the site.

I agree with these conditions.

Advertising

loading...

Newsletter

Please enter your email to receive our free newsletter

Subscribe to news alerts

Aurora Twitter

Advertising